Aug 15th, 2007, 08:01 PM
|
#39 (permalink)
|
|
Banned
Join Date: May 5, 1999 - 12:19 pm
Location: Lost in Transition
Posts: 15,173
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Das Reich
I am looking for a historical source by which it can be proven that the fourth caliph ameerulmomineen Ali reinstated the institution of temporary marriage
|
Well up to my peanut knowledge , I haven’t come across a single historical evidence which stated that AmeerUl momeemin Hazrat Ali reinstated the institution of temporary marriage during the days of his caliphate but u may found that Famous hadis in both Sunni and Shia books ( see Shaih Bhukari , Book 2 , pg 767 , Shaih Muslim , book one , pg 452 and for Shia books see Allama toosi’s Al-ibtisaar , Book 3 , pg 142 , Sheikh Muhammad Bin Hasaan ‘s book ‘ wasail Shia Ala Tahsil.ay masa.il Shariaya , Book 7 , pg 441 ) where He stated that there was a ban imposed on Mutah on day of fata.aay Khyber . You may also get evidence that Hazrat Ibn.ay Abbas was rubked by Hazrat Ali for having soft corner about mutah and was told he could face punishment if he openly give fatwa on this issue .( Shaih Muslim , Fateh Bari and Tafseeray Mazha.ri all have recorded this incident )
Although people like Abu Jafar Muhammad bin Baboya Alqami and Molvi Abdul karim Mushtaq in his book ‘ why do we do Mutah ‘ have recorded my lies on this issue and nazo billah associate them to Imam Baqar and Imam Jafar Sadiq . I don’t acknowledge them even worth reading .
|
|
|