GupShup Forums - View Single Post

Mirch · Oct 10th, 2008, 04:55 PM

It is odd that they would say it, otherwise anything which gives a chance, to some mullahs or their followers, to enjoy a feast will not be forbidden in their eyes. Like celebrating , shab e barat , shab a meraj, eid a milad un nabi , Rajab kay koonday, Chahlum , barsee/death anniversary, bismillah ( thanks giving when a kid starts reading Quran) , ameen( it is thanks giving celebration when a kid finishes reading of Quran), Jum-a-raat ko dada key fateha etc ,etc.
There is nothing in Quran against it and there is no hadees in Bukhari either. So I guess you are safe in this regard , if someone gives fatwa against it then remember fatwa is opinion , not a verdict , so opinion is non binding anyway.

Oct 10th, 2008, 04:55 PM	#3 (permalink)
Mirch Senior Member Join Date: Jan 8, 2008 - 4:31 pm Location: Saat samandar par Posts: 11,666 Blog Entries: 8	It is odd that they would say it, otherwise anything which gives a chance, to some mullahs or their followers, to enjoy a feast will not be forbidden in their eyes. Like celebrating , shab e barat , shab a meraj, eid a milad un nabi , Rajab kay koonday, Chahlum , barsee/death anniversary, bismillah ( thanks giving when a kid starts reading Quran) , ameen( it is thanks giving celebration when a kid finishes reading of Quran), Jum-a-raat ko dada key fateha etc ,etc. There is nothing in Quran against it and there is no hadees in Bukhari either. So I guess you are safe in this regard , if someone gives fatwa against it then remember fatwa is opinion , not a verdict , so opinion is non binding anyway. I am a man with a plan. A plan to live a simple , fulfilling life. Last edited by Mirch; Oct 10th, 2008 at 05:41 PM..