Thats something I wear everyday along with a lip gloss so I am still looking for something good. I really like the hashmi desi kajal thing because it creates a smooth dramatic line but it smudges. Have you found an eye liner which still has that look but doesn't smudge?
Very off topic, but sephora has this awesome stilla eye shodow quad for only $10!
Sephora: Stila Charmed Eye Shadow Palette with 24 Karat Gold: Eyeshadow Sets