Quote:
Originally Posted by AllahkaBanda
the famous saying "whatever flows your boat"
since you have admitted before that you are capable of making ijtihad and you are self learned shakyh then why ask such questions to awam (laypeople) on the board? However, as I a fellow believer, it is my job to remind you to not to speak without knowledge. We understand the Qur'an how the Messenger of Allah (sal-allahu 'alayhi wa sallam) taught us and how the pious scholars from first three Muslim generations taught us and those who followed it afterward. You have categoriezed certain clear commands as commands because it pleases your nafs and then you have categoriezed certain clear commands as suggestions/advices because it doesn't please your nafs and you provide no reasoning or evidence for it.
Let's speak in langauge which you may understand: 1 - How did you reach the conclusion that hijaab is an advice? Would you then also say that the command to men to lower gaze is also an advice? If you disagree, why not?
2 - How did you reach the conclusion that men marrying to women from people of book and women not marrying to other faiths is an advice? |
I have all spelled it all out in my first post. If you cannot comprehend it then I cannot help it.
Instead of asking me how I reached to the conclusions , if you have any strong arguments against my understanding and you can prove with the help of Quran ,hadees or any tafseer or with the help of your own ijtehad , you are more then welcome to do so.
You do not have to be bitter and you do not have to start name calling and there is no need for any pointless comments and judgments you are passing.
Thank you in advance for your co-operation in keeping this a non personal academic discussion.
If you do not have any understanding of Quranic Arabic I would advise you to stay out of this discussion. As for understanding and knowledge of Quran and Hadees and Sunnat. I have spent more than 8 years to understand and learn this religion . I am still learning and this discussion is part of that learning process.