I am sure all of you know about the program that comes on GEO called Alim Online. If not here's a little intro. Its a religious program where the host has 2 scholar guest from Sunni and Shia mazahab. People from Suni and Shia sect call to get answers for their questions.

The Incident.

One of my friend saw this episode live on GEO and here it goes what he told me.

A lady called in and said she has a question and would like to get answer from the scholar. She stated that she went for a Hajj or Umrah (I don't remember if it was for Hajj or Umrah) to Saudi Arabia. And upon arriving in Saudi Arabia when she went to visit Makah she was unable to see the Kabah. Yes thats what she stated that she could NOT see the Kabah. Upon hearing this the Sunni scholar got up with mix feelings of anger and sadness. He (the scholar) asked the caller if she does black magic. The caller (lady) replied yes she has done black magic in the past (I don't remember if she said that she still does it). Upon hearing this the scholar told her that this is the reason she was unable to see the Kabah and advised her to stop doing black magic and she should repent. The scholar also asked the lady to have her husband talk to the scholar and he (scholar) advised the husband to give talak (divorce) the lady because their marriage is not valid anymore.

I know few people here watch this program on GEO and wanted to ask if by any chance they saw this episode? Plus wanted to get your comments on this.

Thank you.

omg

dont see anything on youtube. id expect something like that to be uploaded pretty quick

^ thats what I did after hearing this from my friend. I could not find anything as well on youtube.

how about other desi video sites I would saw ASN or arnold shalwarnicker would know

what a staged drama.

plus how can her husband divorce her, if marriage is already invalid.

Why is the marriage invalid?

Also, a side question. Why doesn't Pakistani govt just hire a few black magicians to solve their problems?

Why black magicians need people to pay them. Why cant they produce black money for themselves. or convert a piece of paper into a $20 bill.

Originally Posted by Robert

what a staged drama.

plus how can her husband divorce her, if marriage is already invalid.

Exactly my pov. It is strange people still believe in this imposter.

Originally Posted by teaser

I am sure all of you know about the program that comes on GEO called Alim Online. If not here's a little intro. Its a religious program where the host has 2 scholar guest from Sunni and Shia mazahab. People from Suni and Shia sect call to get answers for their questions.

The Incident.

One of my friend saw this episode live on GEO and here it goes what he told me.

A lady called in and said she has a question and would like to get answer from the scholar. She stated that she went for a Hajj or Umrah (I don't remember if it was for Hajj or Umrah) to Saudi Arabia. And upon arriving in Saudi Arabia when she went to visit Makah she was unable to see the Kabah. Yes thats what she stated that she could NOT see the Kabah. Upon hearing this the Sunni scholar got up with mix feelings of anger and sadness. He (the scholar) asked the caller if she does black magic. The caller (lady) replied yes she has done black magic in the past (I don't remember if she said that she still does it). Upon hearing this the scholar told her that this is the reason she was unable to see the Kabah and advised her to stop doing black magic and she should repent. The scholar also asked the lady to have her husband talk to the scholar and he (scholar) advised the husband to give talak (divorce) the lady because their marriage is not valid anymore.

I know few people here watch this program on GEO and wanted to ask if by any chance they saw this episode? Plus wanted to get your comments on this.

Thank you.

This happened in Egypt about 20 years ago...I have heard the radio program itself, it's in Arabic...It's nothing to do with GEO...

Ummm i heard this a few years ago...

Originally Posted by WitchDr

Exactly my pov. It is strange people still believe in this imposter.

lol is he still a doctor did or he give up his doctor's degree after they fund that he was fake? BTW, I don't believe in any black or white magics. This is what legends/myths are made off...you're not suppose to believe in this stuff.

Please have that lady contact me... I am in desperate need of seeing some "black magic"... If she can do "yellow" or "pink magic" for me, I'll pay double the amount

maybe they were both hoax stories

Originally Posted by hypnotix-2000

Please have that lady contact me... I am in desperate need of seeing some "black magic"... If she can do "yellow" or "pink magic" for me, I'll pay double the amount

Interesting, I would have thought you are well aware why the Muwwaddathayn (Nas and Falaq) were revealed.

Originally Posted by USResident

Interesting, I would have thought you are well aware why the Muwwaddathayn (Nas and Falaq) were revealed.

Yes brother I am well aware of the reported asbaab-i nuzool...

Salam,

h2k, i feel personally she visited in the night and the lights had gone of near the kaaba, and supposedly since the cover of the kaaba is black I think she couldnt see it. I have no other rational for this.
For heavens sake i can agree with black magic but cant see the kaaba thats quite interesting to me.

Originally Posted by SlaveofAllaah

Salam,

h2k, i feel personally she visited in the night and the lights had gone of near the kaaba, and supposedly since the cover of the kaaba is black I think she couldnt see it. I have no other rational for this.
For heavens sake i can agree with black magic but cant see the kaaba thats quite interesting to me.

Well why don't we explore the possibility that the supposed Alim had this question staged to get some attention?