Bollywood copies Hollywood - Page 2

KraziM3 · Oct 27th, 2009, 03:24 AM

wow theres some major bolly fans out ere. Nywa im sayin ghajini took bits from Bourne trilogy, the way matt damon uses photographs. yes its a copy of memento. Bolly films seem to add their own sleaze factor to the remakes, as in breaking into songs every 5 mins

Esix · Oct 27th, 2009, 03:25 AM

^lolz i havent even seen gajini

Maverick_27 · Oct 27th, 2009, 03:46 AM

Bollywood directors are biggest chappo around the globe.

Copy paste master.

however paralell cenima is gud . but very few ppl like art movie. i think Manesh Jha rocks.

KraziM3 · Oct 27th, 2009, 12:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Esix

^lolz i havent even seen gajini

I havent either...jus seen snippets on TV, I read an article about it - seems we're not missin much.

Punjabee in USA · Oct 27th, 2009, 05:29 PM

And now Hollywood has copied Munnabhai MBBS from Bollywood

Thats a start...

rari389 · Oct 27th, 2009, 09:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Punjabee in USA

And now Hollywood has copied Munnabhai MBBS from Bollywood

Thats a start...

Actually if you consider Munna bhai an original movie then you are wrong! Munna Bhai itself is based on the 1998 hollywood movie titled Patch Adams, which depicts the trule life story of Patch Adams. Dont even say that Munna Bhai is being copied when the movie itself is a copy!!

rari389 · Oct 27th, 2009, 09:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by KraziM3

wow theres some major bolly fans out ere. Nywa im sayin ghajini took bits from Bourne trilogy, the way matt damon uses photographs. yes its a copy of memento. Bolly films seem to add their own sleaze factor to the remakes, as in breaking into songs every 5 mins

Have you seen Memento?? If you have then you will know that Guy Ritichie's character uses photos right out of a polaroid camera, to remember people and places!! In Bourne Matt Damon does use photos but in a very different way, to remember his past not what he has to do on a daily basis like picture of his house or something! Are you getting what i am saying? I am just trying to clarify that it is not copying bourne but Memento.

KraziM3 · Oct 28th, 2009, 08:40 AM

^^Erm....yes i have seen Memento.....n yes i get what u sayin. Sorry for offending you n ur cherished memories of Memento!

I mentioned Bourne cos almost evry1 has seen it, wasnt sure if ppl remembered Memento...both movies use photos for diff conditions. BTW if we are giving such attention to detail i will let u know for a fact that Guy Pearce stars in the film not Guy Ritchie.

FairyTale · Oct 28th, 2009, 08:53 AM

I have seen momento.

If india releases 20 movies a month, 18 are coppied from hollywood and other woods like Irani, kenyan (remember Atif's song) Arabic etc etc. We only come to know about hollywood ones coz we see english moives. The day we started watching other countries movies too, then u will know that remaining 2 movies (out of 20) were coppied from those places. samjhay ke nahin samjhay

and tell u something interesting... Once we were watching a PTV show, some awards show and Daleep Kumar was invited to that as well. Moeen Akhtar was the host. he as usual did an excellent job. After few months there was an indian award show and we were watching this one too. to our surprise we already knew the whole comparing the hosts were doing. coz They were sayig EXACT SAME WORDS WHICH MOIEEN AKHTAR SAID IN HIS SHOW ON PTV

.. that was soo hillarious...

paki_gal420 · Oct 28th, 2009, 05:03 PM

Well Partner was a copy of the will smith starrer "Hitch" It was the SAME with a fat guy playing govinda and will smith being the advisor

rari389 · Oct 28th, 2009, 05:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by KraziM3

^^Erm....yes i have seen Memento.....n yes i get what u sayin. Sorry for offending you n ur cherished memories of Memento!

I mentioned Bourne cos almost evry1 has seen it, wasnt sure if ppl remembered Memento...both movies use photos for diff conditions. BTW if we are giving such attention to detail i will let u know for a fact that Guy Pearce stars in the film not Guy Ritchie.

I apologize for being rude but i am not defending Ghajini or anything if that is what you think. I just wanted to say that Bourne can not be compared to Ghajini in the same way as Memento! And yes i meant Guy Pearce not Guy Ritchie!

sidra0092 · Oct 28th, 2009, 05:53 PM

BollyWood Moviezz - Copied from :

U me aur Hum - The notebook

Qayamat - The rock

Dhoom 2 - Payback

Fool N Final - Snatch

Naksha - Welcome in the jungle

Race - Two lovers

Ghajini - Memento

Zeher - Out of Time

Dilwale Dulhaniya le Jaeinge - The Sure Thing

Judwa - The twin Dragons

Fight club : Member Only : Fight Club

Naukar Biwi ka (Bolly) - Naukar Wohti Da (lollywood)

KraziM3 · Oct 29th, 2009, 03:10 PM

^^Wow bolly really doesnt hold back does it?

Quote:

Originally Posted by rari389

I apologize for being rude but i am not defending Ghajini or anything if that is what you think. I just wanted to say that Bourne can not be compared to Ghajini in the same way as Memento! And yes i meant Guy Pearce not Guy Ritchie!

No harm done..u r right about memento.

Oh yeh i also heard that Baghban is a scene-by-scene copy of some pakistani classic film, i mean dialogue has been copied word for word. Does anyone know the name of the pakistani film?

Punjabee in USA · Oct 29th, 2009, 03:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rari389

Actually if you consider Munna bhai an original movie then you are wrong! Munna Bhai itself is based on the 1998 hollywood movie titled Patch Adams, which depicts the trule life story of Patch Adams. Dont even say that Munna Bhai is being copied when the movie itself is a copy!!

Actually no, Patch Adams is completely different. For starters, the protagonist in Patch Adams is actually a doctor while in Munnabhai he is just pretending to be one. The entire premise is different.

yanzala · Oct 29th, 2009, 04:02 PM

^
i think that is a just a little difference, but patch adams is the main inspiration of munna bhai.

KraziM3 · Oct 29th, 2009, 06:30 PM

munna bhai reminds me of legally blonde...where someone really unlikely becomes a success in a profession..

rari389 · Oct 29th, 2009, 09:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Punjabee in USA

Actually no, Patch Adams is completely different. For starters, the protagonist in Patch Adams is actually a doctor while in Munnabhai he is just pretending to be one. The entire premise is different.

Basing off of a movie doesnt mean they have to make it exaclty the same. The scene after the death of that muslim character! and also a lot of the things are similar if not the same, which i think is because Hirani had this movie in mind when scripting Munna Bhai so thats what i wanted to tell you. How are you saying Hollywood is copying Munna Bhai is out of my understanding!

Enigmatica · Oct 31st, 2009, 07:00 PM

some of the obvious ripoffs include

1. Hey Baby - rip of Three men and a baby ..(totally)
2. Salaam-e-Ishq - adaptation of Love Actually
3. Dil Bole Haddipa - loosely a copy of She's the Man starring Amanda Bynes
4. God tusi great ho - Bruce Almighty

ChicaGurl · Nov 4th, 2009, 12:42 PM

veer zaara is a copy of pakistani film tere pyar mein sorry for going kinda offtopic

waleedhbk · Nov 6th, 2009, 12:19 AM

even ghajini was a copy of a hollywood movie